期刊论文

Strategies for Realizing the Social Effect of Judicial Decisions and Their Optimization

中文

环球法律评论

1009-6728

2023

45

04

209-224

2022年度中国法学会部级法学研究课题一般项目“人民法院防止返贫的司法策略——基于2020-2021年间208份裁判文书的实证研究”“项目编号:CLS(2022)C05”的研究成果

本校为第一机构

司法实践中，我国法院已将防止返贫的社会效果纳入司法考量。案例显示，人民法院防止返贫的具体裁量存在“积极适用”与“相对审慎”两种裁判立场。这两种裁判立场的产生有其内部成因，主要体现为法官在不同案件结构中所处的“调停者”与“监管者”地位影响了司法自由裁量权的行使。基于此，法官形成了两种具有典型差异的司法策略：严格规范主义司法策略和社会功能主义司法策略。然而，这两种司法策略的同时运用可能影响防止返贫社会效果的有效实现和司法的公正价值。对此，我们应当从两个层面完善司法策略的适用规则：一是确立严格规范主义司法策略的优先适用地位，二是明确社会功能主义司法策...

In recent years,China has made remarkable achievements in poverty eradication,and how to prevent people lifted out of poverty from slipping back into poverty is a longterm issue faced by China that not only affects the actual effect of poverty eradication but also deter...MORE In recent years,China has made remarkable achievements in poverty eradication,and how to prevent people lifted out of poverty from slipping back into poverty is a longterm issue faced by China that not only affects the actual effect of poverty eradication but also determi...