期刊论文

On the Optimization of Structure of Legality Review of Legislation--From the Perspective of Reconstructing the Relationship between Formal Legality and Substantive Legality

中文

华中师范大学学报(人文社会科学版)

1000-2456

2024

63

1

34-44

10.19992/j.cnki.1000-2456.2024.01.004

国家社会科学基金一般项目“中国共产党领导立法的系统研究”(21XFX014) 湖北省社会科学基金一般项目(后期资助项目)“地方性法规合法性控制研究”(2021066)。

本校为第一机构

从现有理论来看,立法的形式合法性与实质合法性审查呈现出“并行”状态,主要表现为两者“功能趋同”“位阶相同”“互为整体”,处于重复审查的状态。这导致实质合法性审查在理论上陷入冗余困境,实践中也往往处于搁置不用的状态,严重影...展开更多 从现有理论来看,立法的形式合法性与实质合法性审查呈现出“并行”状态,主要表现为两者“功能趋同”“位阶相同”“互为整体”,处于重复审查的状态。这导致实质合法性审查在理论上陷入冗余困境,实践中也往往处于搁置不用的状态,严重影响立法合法性审查工作的开展。优化立法合法性审查结构需要重构形式合法性与实质合法性审查的关系。鉴于合法性审查的...

According to the existing theories,the review of the formal and substantive legality are“paralleled”with each other,which is manifested in that they are“convergent in function”,“equal in order”,and“integral for each other”,which means that they are duplicative.As a resu...MORE According to the existing theories,the review of the formal and substantive legality are“paralleled”with each other,which is manifested in that they are“convergent in function”,“equal in order”,and“integral for each other”,which means that they are duplica...